Games that Failed or are Failing your expectations

Always a nice subjective topic.

I was thinking that sometimes a game can be great for many, and then lead to disappointment for a few from over heightened expectations. Or a game can end up being way better than we expected.

While CSW is often the reality check, sometimes too far the other way for my liking, sometimes we just go buy that game, open it and are full of subjective "MEH" to coin then internet shoulder shrug.

Some highlights from early 2013.

  • RAF, wow this one just was a crushing disappointment. Why? You have so few choices to make that it becomes a wrote exercise. I promise to try again, to find the noble spirit of August/Sept '41.
  • Drive on Pyongyang...I deserved this for buying at pre pub prices. Not finished. regurgitated from a axis of evil concept 10 yrs ago to take advantage of current events. Map errors, and incorrect VC' and terrible map layout took anything positive from this game (and there is a lot of great ideas in this game) and tossed them out the window
  • Wagram Battles mag....OMG. After 2 turns. I looked at the turn track, then back to the stack of chits per turn. Then at the counters. quietly decided that I clearly was not an erudite student of Napoleon and that I should just let this be a lesson. I'm not smart enough to appreciate this game.
  • White Star Rising Great game, but I really am at quota for WWII. great components and cool scenarios with easy rules. Yet I play WaW a lot, its much deadlier cousin. I'll stick to that.
  • PanzerArmee Afrika AH. Yeah an older game. After a few turns of this, the level of abstraction was so high for me that I realized that DAK2 was laughing its ass of at me literally behind my back. Bought for cheap, its a game that would make a nice starting point in assessing the evolution of game design in the theatre. To see just how thinking evolved around this logistically laden, leader focused conflict played out in various games. I was not expecting much...and received less.

Views: 1088

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Just remember, Kevin, that before PANZERARMEE AFRIKA all we really had was AH's venerable AFRIKA KORPS.  I can't play either of them today, despite strong pulls of nostalgia.  For "small" games on this theater, I just go for ROMMEL IN THE DESERT.  Can't help it.

Oh man I so understand. I was really trying get my head around some early design. It did not help that I had dak2 on the table behind me, giggling at my futility.

I was hoping to play several afrika titles and compare and contrast. After all I'm still a boy gamer amongst u veterans.

Some updates... A Most Dangerous Time.

Grrr. I will best this game.

Strike North from Command Games was meh (historical scenario)

I'm fearful that Panzer 2nd Ed. may end up being a bust. I like it...but...I'm not 100% sure. Really want it to be all that and a bag of chips!

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Will Kohudic left a comment for Eric Walters
"Hi Eric, and thank you. I work full time and have a big family, so it would be most accurate to say…"
6 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Carlos Díaz
"Carlos, welcome to the CONSIMWORLD Social website!  Quite a large collection you have, but…"
8 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Rob B
"Welcome to the CONSIMWORLD Social website, Rob!  You appear to have some eclectic tastes in…"
8 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Will Kohudic
"Welcome to the CONSIMWORLD Social Website, Will!  If you only have a few titles, at least you…"
8 hours ago
Profile IconWill Kohudic, Rob B and Carlos Díaz joined ConsimWorld
8 hours ago
Jeff Duffy updated their profile
Friday
Mike Palmer posted a discussion

Cora, The Normandy Campaign Decision Games

Hi, I'm currently learning the rules for Cobra, The Normandy campaign by Decision Games. I hope…See More
Thursday
Zachary Miller left a comment for Eric Walters
"Thanks for the hearty welcome, Eric. I really like COH 3rd edition. The extra roll really adds that…"
Thursday

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service