Lately I've been collecting a lot of games from the first "golden age" of wargaming... the 70s.  I was wondering which game people think is the most underrated game of that period?

Views: 697

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Dixie? Just kidding (although I still play this one once in a blue moon - must be the attraction of Confederate armored brigades!). I've heard people claim that The Plot to Assassinate Hitler didn't deserve its bad press, but I must confess I could never get into the game when it was released...

Excellent suggestions and I have them both in my collection. Dixie had some interesting innovations, though maybe wasted on the game itself. (It was kind of a wacky idea, but THAT was the 70s!) And I agree on the Plot, too.

Thanks for the feedback.

Dave

Can't say I'm thrilled with Plot. 

A lot of people despised Armada. I thought it was a damned fine light game on a subject that no one was touching.

Siege of Constantinople also got bad press, and I thought it was quite good.

I agree on both counts. Armada (with errata) does an excellent job at simulating the situation.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who liked Armada and Siege of Constantinople. I thought I was amongst the lunatic fringe with those titles. If Enrinco enjoyed them, I don't feel so bad! One of the main reasons I liked SPI over Avalon Hill was that they were making games on subjects off the beaten path. I can't speak for anyone else, but I have two copies of The Punic Wars and still enjoy playing the game - particularly the First Punic War (Hannibal and Scipio be damned!).

The 70's restriction kills one of the most innovative SPI games of all times - Tito.

Only one year off, but it showed the kind of excellent ideas that just ended up panned by most S&T readers.

If it wasn't the traditional WWII stuff, people weren't happy.

Air Assault On Crete (Avalon Hill) -- even without the mini-game Invasion of Malta.  Most people preferred the latter, but not I.  This game was a real nail biter and was much better than anything else on the subject. Still is, even over three and half decades later.  

I understand that it was a pretty good game, though the box art was a bit off setting. Thanks forthw suggestion.

'Battlefleet Mars' was a guilty pleasure..my 'historical' gaming friends of the time didn't approve

That's a game I have not played enough times. Picked it up late (90's?) and it really impressed me.

The tactical space combat component was a real mind bender for me..it required two maps and two counters for each individual unit to be represented in 3D space..luckily it's not essential to play and I discarded it early on..

I don't think it added much. The cool part was the moving planets.

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

William George Sterner left a comment for Eric Walters
"The favorites are cause the hold the most memories when I started playing these back in the…"
7 hours ago
Dave Hall posted photos
yesterday
Eric Walters and Mike Palmer are now friends
yesterday
Dave Hall updated their profile
yesterday
Jonathan F posted a status
"Eric, thanks. i got super busy right as i joined and had to put on hold the plunge. now it's on!"
yesterday
Dave Hall joined Jon Compton's group
Thumbnail

Gaming Modern and Hypothetical Conflict

Games that deal with modern or hypothetical conflict have become rare. The challenges that would-be…See More
yesterday
Jason Weiser commented on Jay Czarnecki's group Baltimore-DC-Northern Virginia Area Gamers
"Am long time wargamer in the Fairfax area. Have a few GMT, Gamers, GDW, and AH titles I would love…"
yesterday
Eloy Muñoz Galvez and Sebastián Alarcón Diaz are now friends
yesterday

Members

CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2018   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service