Don Chappell made a comment regarding my oft-expressed skepticism regarding OA applications on so-called "soft factors." Attached is a rather ambitious attempt at this, entitled "Gaming and Simulating Ethno-Political Conflicts," presented in August 2006 at the Descartes Conference on Mathematical Models in Counterterrorism, written by Barry Silverman, Gnana Bharathy, and Benjamin Nye out of University of Pennsylvania. This is also posted online at URL:
http://www.seas.upenn.edu/~barryg/EthnoPoliGame.pdf

These kinds of models are great at performing "control functions" in command post exercises and the like...great fun for players...but I'd be extremely reticent to use them for predictive/validation purposes--Godel's Incompleteness Theorem applies here.

Views: 73

Attachments:

Replies to This Discussion

Good heads up, Eric!

I'll try to read this over the weekend. It sounds interesting.
Jon Compton's editorial in the Winter 2007 edition of FIRE AND MOVEMENT got me thinking...and so I fulfilled my duty as one of the staff-bloggers-at-large over at the Small Wars Journal website Check it out at:

Problems and Prospects of Defense Counterinsurgency Wargaming
I'll read this paper shortly. Regarding mathematical modeling of terrorism, I wrote a paper a few years ago in which I did just that. Here's a link for your entertainment: http://joncompton.com/ViolentSystems.pdf. The model needs some respecification in that it's not empirically estimable as constructed. I think I would probably drop the life-cycle equation for starters, along with a few other things.
Eric, The paper references Green and Armstrong (2003), but doesn't have the citation in the references section. Are you familiar with the work that they're citing? See the first paragraph in the introduction.
This was an interesting paper.
I wonder if the board game they mention, "BigWig", will ever see the light of day...

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Eric Walters replied to Greg A Siegfriedt-Wilson's discussion MechWar 77 etc
"There's also a good number of variant counter graphics and map versions available in the Files…"
2 hours ago
Eric Walters replied to Greg A Siegfriedt-Wilson's discussion MechWar 77 etc
"From the Boardgame Geek entry for the game: Magazine References: Moves Article Index: Number 18,…"
3 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Carlo Amaddeo
"Welcome to the CONSIMWORLD Website, Carlo!  I've not played TAC AIR or KNIGHTS OF THE AIR…"
yesterday
Carlo Amaddeo is now a member of ConsimWorld
yesterday
Eric Walters left a comment for Donald R Garlit
"Donald, I write and teach decision-forcing historical case method to my students and have been for…"
yesterday
Donald R Garlit left a comment for Eric Walters
"Dear Eric, Thanks for the welcome.  I have played war games for decades. One observation as…"
yesterday
Joseph replied to Chuang Shyue Chou's discussion What are you reading?
"Read: "Empire of Horses: The First Nomadic Civilization and the Making of China" by John…"
Wednesday
Eric Walters commented on Kid's photo
Thumbnail

Coldwar

"Heck, I'd use this game for my ASL and ASLSK games, it looks so good!  I can imagine a…"
Wednesday

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service