I've got two house rule ideas up over at my blog and I'd really like some comments!

Views: 100

Replies to This Discussion

I'd like to comment on House Rule #2:
This idea makes some sense. However, it might make flotilla craft too resilient. I too find the way flotilla craft die like flies in GWAS/SWWAS to be more than irksome. I've been working on my own solution over the past several months. It's difficult to find the right balance between vulnerabililty and resiliency. It's also difficult to balance the dire threat torpedo attacks represented in the minds of flag officers with the rather limited results that took place historically.

One aspect of the equation that GWAS/SWWAS has never attempted to take into account is that of the human factor. Men in unarmored ships faced by hot enemy fire will often veer from a direct attack rather than be annihilated. I'm working on a torpedo attack routine that includes this human factor. The routine would also limit the exposure of flotillas to enemy fire during a general action and include range attenuation.
I think they have admitted that because players don't have the same considerations as their real world counterparts (i.e., ships are expensive to replace and sailors take time to train) that they take many more risks with ships than would happen in real life. I'm not sure how you get around that.

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Andy Loakes posted a status
"LYG's June Upadate is Complete. See what we have for you here: www.likeyyankgames.co.uk"
5 hours ago
Dan Geer posted a status
"I've been looking for a Vassal (something akin) module for Proud Monster Deluxe. Where can I find one? Thnaks"
yesterday
Nathan posted a video

Guide to Operation Overlord Wargames [D-Day, Normandy, 6 June 1944]

Guide to Operation Overloard Games [D-Day, Normandy, 6 June 1944]
yesterday
Eric Walters commented on Kid's photo
Thumbnail

Hue

"Really appreciate the annotations on the map, showing those historically significant locations!"
yesterday
Kid posted a photo

Hue

Part of Hue south-east-of the river. To use for the 'Sweep' actions of the US Marines capturing the…
Thursday
Eric Walters left a comment for Dan Geer
"Welcome to the CONSIMWORLD Social Website, Dan.  I'm sure you've found the ASL group…"
Thursday
Dan Geer is now a member of ConsimWorld
Thursday
Eric Walters commented on Kid's photo
Thumbnail

ASL PTO 2

"All sorts of tactical possibilities on this board!  "
Thursday

Groups

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service