Wonder what you consider the 'best' games about the Bulge as for ergonomics/uncomplexity vs historical relevance ?
I love Tigers in the Mist (GMT) - naturally, because I'm #1 in its Ladder now ;-) but it has its quirks - "too harsh" irreversible attrition; counterattacks strongly punished; Bastogne rarely is worth leaving as an "island"...
Also played Bulge (AH/Smithsonian 1991) and it has its quirks too, more severe - notably in the victory conditions. Germans can infiltrate, encircle and liquidate a few US divisions, then retreat with minimal loss off map to Germany... (that would mean abandon the Siegfried Line ?!?)
The new Fast Action Battles: Bulge (FAB1) looks intriguing... still divisions as basic units isn't too little choice ?

... For the heavy side: I've heard good about the classic Wacht am Rhein; wonder what other good/better alternatives there are, and in what cases the extra work is worth the better story...

Thanks for thinking about this ! Mircea

Views: 45

Replies to This Discussion

For me, the best one I ever played was SPI's Battles for the Ardennes.

I wish I had a copy now.

Right now, on the list of games to play are two bulge games; SPI's Wacht am Rhein and 'Iron Tide: Panzers in the Ardennes'

L2's Bitter Woods looks really nice; I have often condiered its purchase.
Without a doubt Iron Tide, More simulation- less shelf time. I could be predjudiced of course, being that I designed my favorite system into the Bulge.
I'm finally going to get a chance to play Iron Tide sometime this month. Looking forward to it, beautiful looking game.
The original AH Battle of the Bulge game (1965) is often knocked for the historical accuracy of its deployment, but wherever I've read this no-one's given specifics. I've just checked the game's initial US depoyment with maps and information on the US Army military history website and it seems perfectly in order. Nothing glaringly out of position. Does anyone know the precise nature of the criticism of this game in terms of deployment?
For simple, you probably can't beat One-Page Bulge (Steve Jackson Games), though it's now out of print.

Soon to come, though, is Bulge 20 (Victory Point Games), which looks like a novel, command-centered approach.

My first historical wargame was the 1965 edition of AH's Bulge, which I bought in 1970 or so. Liked the 1981 version better. Didn't care for the 1991 "Smithsonian" edition.

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Armand R. Cingolani III is now a member of ConsimWorld
11 hours ago
Oliver S. Linßen joined Matt Severns's group
Thumbnail

MARKETPLACE -

Buyin', Sellin' and good ol' fashioned horse tradin.......Can't find what you need? Go to the CSW…See More
yesterday
Mark DAgosta commented on Gilbert Collins's blog post Hex grid as a file
"Gilbert, I'm not on CSW very often, so please contact me at mark @ grognard.com if you still…"
Tuesday
Mark DAgosta commented on Gilbert Collins's blog post Hex grid as a file
"Gilbert, have you gotten the file you were looking for yet?"
Tuesday
Markm1767 commented on Markm1767's photo
Thumbnail

nap1

"It is like Napoleon at Waterloo and was fast easy and enjoyable.  After seeing that old 1970…"
Sunday
Markm1767 commented on Markm1767's photo
Thumbnail

bob2

"Played 2 games of Battle of the Bulge by Dark City Game. First game was a fight in the woods with…"
Sunday
Markm1767 posted photos
Sunday
Profile IconRandy Stumman and Dan Crudele joined Ed Beach's group
Thumbnail

Great Campaigns of the American Civil War

Fans of the GCACW series. Titles include: Stonewall Jackson's Way, Here Come The Rebels, Roads to…See More
Saturday

Groups

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2018   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service