Starting to learn EFS; am I making a mistake by learning "retrofitted Typhoon" first?

Hello Gents,

I just retired and now I finally have time to learn my EFS games.  I really want to start with Typhoon because it's my favorite campaign, but I keep running across statements like "The original Typhoon rules don't allow the pocket at Vyazma to occur, nor do they include the very important Soviet HQ rules.  You should really use the current  EFS Barbarossa rules instead to make the game right." 

Okay, so according to the GMT downloads page the "current EFS rulebook" is the Kiev To Rostov rules.  I also found the "Retrofitting Typhoon to Barbarossa" article and posted all the changes in pencil to the KtR rulebook.

The retrofit article also directs me to ignore many of the Typhoon player aid charts in favor of the KtR charts, so now I'll be using a mix of charts from both games.   And of course there is counter errata to the Typhoon counters that I can't do anything about except remember it when I encounter one of the affected counters.  

I expect I'll spend the coming weeks learning and playing Typhoon in this fashion, and I'm wondering whether I'm going to encounter any unforeseen problems along the way.  For example, I'll still need to use the original Typhoon Playbook for the scenarios.  The retrofit article includes update information for the scenarios, but I have not been able to find any comments on how well they work. 

I'd hate to put two weeks into Typhoon only to find "Oops, this isn't going to work" because of some fundamental retrofit compatibility problem I was unaware of.

So can you old hands give me some advice?  Has anyone actually played "retrofitted Typhoon" and found the retrofit adequate to play the scenarios using the current EFS rules without problems? 

Thanks, guys.

Ian

Views: 56

Help Center

Latest Activity

Rick Miller joined Ed Beach's group
Thumbnail

Great Campaigns of the American Civil War

Fans of the GCACW series. Titles include: Stonewall Jackson's Way, Here Come The Rebels, Roads to…See More
9 hours ago
Rick Miller updated their profile
9 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Martin Mayers
"Welcome to the ConsimWorld Social website, Martin!  I'm with you--ASL, ASL, and more ASL.…"
10 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Rick Miller
"Rick, Welcome to the ConsimWorld Social website!  I'm anxiously awaiting my own copy of…"
10 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for john pysz
"John, You sure play some classics!  I have some good memories of S&T PLEASANT HILL!…"
10 hours ago
Profile Iconjohn pysz, Rick Miller and Martin Mayers joined ConsimWorld
10 hours ago
Alexander Martin left a comment for Jon H
"my email address is alexander.lee.martin@gmail.com Cheers Alex"
10 hours ago
Alexander Martin left a comment for Jon H
"That would be delightful. I have missed the entire ASL revolution. Bulge81, AK, TRC, FE any…"
10 hours ago

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2018   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service