Post your questions and recommendations for NJ Hickman's excellent QUICK START RULES (QSR) for FIGHTING WINGS. These rules are very concise, so a few things do need clarifying for new players who don't have the benefit of a tutor/more experienced player! Hickman also admits to some errors in the example of play within the QS Scenarios, so we can discuss them here so newbies aren't confused. Attached are the latest PDF files for the rules, scenarios, and map from Uncle Ted's (the resource site NJ Hickman runs)!

Views: 293

Attachments:

Replies to This Discussion

We definitely need some sort of blurb on how to count range, particularly when either the shooter or the target is on a hexside. Of course, the full rules set has a diagram that spells that out neatly, but in the interest of brevity, we need something terse for the QSR. Would it be to much to suggest that "range in hexes between firer and shooter--when one or both aircraft is on a hexside--should be determined by assuming the hexide aircraft is/are in the adjacent hex closest to the other"???
EXAMPLE OF PLAY error? Looking at the otherwise exceptional and easy-to-understand example of play that comes with NJ Hickman's THE SUN AGAINST THE STARS scenarios, the following situation raises questions:

In the second column of page seven, Webster is considering is flight attitude options for Game Turn 1. In the first full paragraph of that column, the example notes that "If he elects to transition at the maximum rate of ET, he may transition four steps around the circle, which would put him into an inverted steep dive (STD). Furtherore, as he starts in the area where he will push "With Gravity," he is allowed to make an extra step of transition, so he could end in an inverted Shallow Dive (SHD)."

Now, doesn't this conflict with the following from the QSR: Under 3.4 TRANSITIONS PROCEDURE, the second paragraph, third sentence says: "Push transitions are limited to a maximum rate of HT-2." This is also parroted in the chart entitled Flight Attitudes Diagram.

Webster doesn't do this, of course, but the fact that option is even brought up makes me wonder.
Think in the example the plane could go inverted so the "push" would really a "pull" to dive (still with gravity) thus negating the HT 2 limitation. A later game turn shows a large attitude transition while inverted (game turn 3 or 4?).

Studying the QSR it looks like the quickest way to dive is to roll inverted while transitioning to a steep dive or go vertical. Might have to try this out next game.(which Eric should show up to). ....
QSR 3.1 is now available! This fixes the range hex counting problem and has a few other things included as well....
Attachments:

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

skippen joined Ed Beach's group
Thumbnail

Great Campaigns of the American Civil War

Fans of the GCACW series. Titles include: Stonewall Jackson's Way, Here Come The Rebels, Roads to…See More
1 hour ago
skippen joined Brian Blad's group
Thumbnail

Great Battles of the American Civil War

This is the place to discuss GMT/Richard Berg's GBACW series of games
1 hour ago
Joseph replied to Chuang Shyue Chou's discussion What are you reading?
"Read: Islam at the Gates: How Christendom Defeated the Ottoman Turks" by Diane Moczar. A…"
2 hours ago
AR Usog added a discussion to the group Victory Games
Thumbnail

Central America

Anyone play this game recently?See More
3 hours ago
AR Usog joined Joe Steadman's group
Thumbnail

Bulge or Bust

For those of use who are addicted to gaming and studying the Ardennes Offensive....
3 hours ago
AR Usog joined Andy Brown's group
Thumbnail

ColdWarGaming

The Cold War and all it's parts.... I also would include Vietnam and Korea.See More
3 hours ago
AR Usog joined Chuck S.'s group
Thumbnail

All things SPI

Dedicated to the old school game titles by SPI!
3 hours ago
AR Usog joined Brian Blad's group
Thumbnail

All Things Napoleonic

This is the place to discuss all thing Napoleonic
3 hours ago

Groups

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2019   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service