Randy an I are going to play a campaign around mid July. Using My 6 Page Napoleonics, left side of page bellow.

Wargames Medford Oregon

Here are the main problems i have encountered with campaigns

if supply rules are used the Campaign is usually decided at the map level and no battles are fought.

If fortification rules are used the campaign winds up being sieges


If there is not a minimum size for armies there are lots of stupid battles where an infantry battalion marches on and a cavalry squadron rides around it the whole game.

Attachment is my incomplete preliminary draft of the Map segment of the campaign. If any one wants to check for game breaking mechanisms your feed back is appreciated. I'll be working on this off on on between now and T time.

Views: 40

Attachments:

Replies to This Discussion

Lance,

I'm not interested in Napoleonics but what I've found with most campaigns over the years is that they attempt to be too "big" . . . that is to say that they try to accomplish too much.

You mention "supply" . . . while this is really a significant factor in "the operational art", it can easily become both a bookkeeping nightmare and a deterent to physical encounters on the table top.

I suggest that you consider limiting the scope of your campaign. Charles S. Grant has a lovely short campaign in the first of his "Scenario" books that I like . . . but even better is his new "Raid on St. Michel". It is a series of battles that would make an excellent small campaign. I need to get some more troops painted in order to run it, but it looks like a LOT of fun.


-- Jeff

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Peter Loop updated their profile
9 hours ago
John Kranz posted a discussion

Site outage

We are working to fix several of our web sites that are offline due to DNS errors. We are working…See More
Tuesday
Joseph replied to Chuang Shyue Chou's discussion What are you reading?
"Read: "Before & After Alexander: The Legend and Legacy of Alexander the Great" by…"
Sunday
Steve K commented on Steve K's blog post Games I'm Playing 2020
"Tiny Battles' Okinawa! after one month: US 10th Army pushing against the Shuri Line."
Feb 22
Joseph replied to John Kranz's discussion What are you playing?
"Played: "Sword of Rome" by GMT. Did not finish but all had lots of fun. Playing the new…"
Feb 20
Profile IconGilles and PabloM joined ConsimWorld
Feb 20
John Kranz posted a blog post
Feb 20
Steve K commented on Steve K's blog post Games I'm Playing 2020
"The Saturday Group played GMT's "Sword of Rome".  Only made it through 2 turns…"
Feb 18

Groups

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service