My first was the old AH edition of TOBRUK. I had learned and was playing PANZERBLITZ and PANZER LEADER up until then and I had absolutely no miniatures experience whatsoever. When TOBRUK was advertised in the AH catalog, it just seemed to be dripping in realism. Now, realism wasn't what made AH famous--it was games, wargames to be sure, but games that could be played and made great competition venues. TOBRUK seemed to be a step off the precipice. Well, I plopped down my 12 bucks (earned cutting grass in my neighborhood) and held my breath. I remember when the game arrived and I sucked in my breath looking at the counters, the rules, the extensive charts, the casualty roster pad--even the featureless map didn't dissuade me. Jumped right in. And thought that this game was the cat's meow. Until SQUAD LEADER was published in 1977. I never picked up TOBRUK again after that, but I had a pretty large hole in my desert gaming for a long while. Now, I never did get DESERT WAR by SPI--but I'd played MECH WAR 77, PANZER 44, and KAMPFPANZER and just didn't think much of si-move at that scale. So there wasn't any desert gaming for me until West End's TANK LEADER series, and I did all three of them, to include the last title on the Africa theater. Oh, those counters were a bit garish (and for the Commonwealth, they were a bit tough to read). But I was having those tactical thrills again. But the system didn't seem to catch on for some reason, so I had difficulties finding opponents (bad graphics did not help here). It wasn't until AH published WEST OF ALAMEIN in the ASL series that I was rip roaring in the desert in a way I hadn't since the original TOBRUK. And ASL just "felt" right. Far more than TOBRUK ever did--and it moved a lot faster than TOBRUK ever did.

Now, to be fair, Yaquinto players had "88," which was one of three games that were heavily miniatures based. Unlike TOBRUK, this game had terrain depictions and the system didn't feel quite as onerous. I never played this particular game or ARMOR, its Western Front counterpart, but I did play PANZER (the Eastern Front version) quite a lot. Additionally, GDW also did THE SANDS OF WAR and THE SANDS OF WAR EXPANSION SET which had a lot of WW II North Africa scenarios. But the system and components never really gelled for me--felt too vanilla. Nothing horribly wrong, just seemed a bit flavorless. And in the S&T issue with PANZER BATTLES, we find one small scenario set in North Africa, but it really was a "teaser" for a new platoon-level tactical system that was eventually published as MECH WAR 2.

Now there are more choices than ever before. We also have ADVANCED TOBRUK system which is awesome--you can jump into a fairly detailed Africa tactical system right away, without having to learn a huge rulebook and buy a bunch of other stuff you need to start playing it. We have PANZER GRENADIER'S DESERT RATS and AFRIKA KORPS, with add ons for the South Africans and the like. ASL, ATS, and PG alone give us a great panoply of desert gaming. I won't be surprised if Mark Walker eventually takes on North Africa for his Lock 'N Load series. For those who like man-to-man games, I think we even have a SERGEANTS! module from Lost Battalion Games that covers it. Lastly, I just saw that MMP is doing a company-level tactical game on Bir Hacheim involving the Germans and the Free French. So WWII North Africa tactical wargaming is alive and quite well.

What are your favorites? What is still missing? What do you wish for? Let us know!

Views: 271

Replies to This Discussion

A little late but, back on the time, I played AH Tobruk and Yaquinto's 88 until the components were worn out (I still have them to prove it), although I bought the ASL line to the Red Barrcades module, I never played it, couldn't find the time to learn/play it or people to do it with, so my West of Alamein module never saw the light of day or the surface of a table. After some twenty years out of (war)gaming I was looking for ASL material over the internet in 2002 and found ATS and now its the tactical North African game I'm playing.
Carlos, we may see "88" make a comeback yet...StrikeNet games is collaborating with GMT (or so their website says) on bringing all the games of Jim Day's Yaquinto PANZER series back. I never got to play it, but did play PANZER so I know the system--and I too played my copy of TOBRUK until the counters were round. As both an ASL player and an occasional ATS player, you aren't missing all that much--sure, there's a bit more color and chrome, but the complexity is often too much for even die-hard ASL players. The desert war seems to get the least amount of play in those circles. I must say that Critical Hit has done an excellent job with ATS and all those expansion sets for ADVANCED TOBRUK. Hey, if it works, go with it!
Eric, good to know that Panzer is still alive and probably will get a GMT treatment. Although I cannot "force" my actual gaming group to play ASL, I'll not part with what I have on the series :) The fact is that it is hard to have them to play ATS in a proper way, they just want to use tanks, I'm ok with that, but theres so much being wasted in such a way to play it. I finally got a new gamer that (at least for the moment) states that he wants to learn the hole system, aiming to play the Kursk, Panther Line and Omaha ATS modules among others, only time will tell if it will happen. In the mean time I just got Heroes of the Blitzkrieg and Combat Commander:Europe as two more "palatable" tactical games. So many games to play, so little time to do it !

Chuck, ATS stands for Advanced Tobruk System, a tactical system in the same scale as ASL. It is simpler though, with the basic game having only 4 pages, and the full system some 60. There are modules set in all the major theatres of operations, the Arab-Israeli wars, Korea. And ACW and The Great War in the works.


Help Center

Latest Activity

Profile IconSteen Kastoft Hansen and Gerard Vandervelden joined ConsimWorld
David left a comment for Jamey Cribbs
"I will look forward to meeting to play some wargames once we get past the pandemic. We met some…"
David left a comment for Shawn King
"I noticed you played Enemy Coast Ahead. Which of the games have you played - Doolitte Raid or…"
John Kranz posted a blog post

Early Access: CSW Community

We are now open for early access for our all-new CSW Community.We invite you to join today for…See More
John Kranz commented on John Kranz's blog post Moving to New Platform
"We're now providing early access to our new CSW Community platform. Anyone can sign-up for…"
Ian Schofield posted photos
Daniel Windham left a comment for Kim Kanger
"Hi Kim!  I just did a open box review of Critical Hit's ASL comp for Dien BIen Phu. I…"
Daniel Windham left a comment for Carl Nogueira
"Hi Carl, I did a video review of Critical Hit's Dien Bien Phu. I know you did some scenarios…"



CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2021   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service