I wish to make DBP a fast playing tournament game. I will introduce a make or break system. The Viet Minh places a regiment order marker on a French strongpoint. That regiment is now ordered to continue its assault until that strongpoint is reached and conquered. While reaching it, the regiment will suffer two consequences of its assault as well as battle results (in addition to losses). The consequences are fatigue and distress. The assault will continue with movement and fighting until the order marker is reached or the units reatreat - make or break.

After each movement and assault a unit gets increasingly tired until it gets exhausted (two sides of a marker). The more tired it gets the lower its effectiveness is. After each fighting, results of distress may accumulate. First is gets disrupted and then eventually shaken (again, two sides of a marker). So a unit that starts fresh will eventually end up both exhausted and shaken, but still able to fight though.

Along the way it might also get a battle result as surpressed, which will stop an assault. A regiment can continue until the steam blows off and hopefully it will have reached its objective before its battalions receive retreat results, perhaps due to their increasingly poor status.

The trick is to know how far in among the French the Viet Minh should place the order markers. To far in the units might not be able to reach it and take unnecessary losses in the process of their struggle to get there. Also, failure is not good for morale. Not far in enough, the gains might not be that impressive and, who knows, maybe you could have taken that extra strongpoint also. And, of course, success is good for morale.

http://www.legionwargames.com/legion_dien_bien_phu.html

Views: 94

Comment

You need to be a member of ConsimWorld to add comments!

Join ConsimWorld

Comment by Eric Walters on April 23, 2012 at 5:45am

KIm, I think this title may kick me off of playing GDW's venerable CITADEL game on this battle.  This looks like a very interesting design from your descriptions of it!

Comment by Kim Kanger on April 22, 2012 at 8:41am

Eric, thanks for the preorder!

VM has a large force, probably as many battalions as the French has companies. VM will also be able to concentrate at places while the French wont be able to be strong everywhere. But France will have some very good units in reserve which can be thrown into an ongoing assault to counter a VM assault.

France's only hope of victory is this: VM has a lot of replacements but these were newly recruited rookies quickly gathered around DBP. When a regiment (consisting of three battalions and a support company) takes too many replacements it will start to get a lower morale value. This morale will get worse as the regiment continues to replace. Not only are the hardcore professionals being replaced by rookies but the rookies themselves start to get increasingly unwilling to rush into the meatgrinder.

VM will receive a morale point (one to three) for each strongpoint taken. VM must have a certain number of morale points each game turn (there were negotiations going on in Europe between VM and France. Both sides had a very strong interest of being in control of DBP when the talks started in earnest), so if Giap is too cautious his army will loose faith. If he is too aggressive his battle trained army will kill itself on the wires of DBP and become unfit for any further assault. If the French player manages to defend and slow down the VM assault and kill as many steps as possible while saving enough of his own units it might come to a point where the VM player will not be able to continue.

Comment by Eric Walters on April 22, 2012 at 3:18am

After reading this, I put in a pre-order.  I very much am taken with this description of the system--I get the sense of timing and pacing of assaults, not only for each one, but for prosecution of the siege overall.  Am sure this will put the Viet Minh player on a tightrope.  Curious on how it plays for the French, so you'll have to tell us more, Kim!

Help Center

Latest Activity

John Kranz left a comment for Craig Martin
"My bad, Craig.  Stupid typo when typing my message to you and I can't edit and fix it. :-("
2 hours ago
John Kranz left a comment for Craig Martin
"Greg, thanks for joining. I really enjoyed my time back in the 1980's when I lived in Palm…"
3 hours ago
Craig Martin is now a member of ConsimWorld
3 hours ago
Joseph replied to Chuang Shyue Chou's discussion What are you reading?
"Read: "Verses for the Dead" by Preston & Child. A Pendergast Novel. Pendergast is an…"
yesterday
Profile IconSteve Boone and Allen Rines joined ConsimWorld
yesterday
Jo Bader commented on Jo Bader's group Second Front
Wednesday
Jo Bader commented on Jo Bader's group Second Front
"at the green beach...."
Tuesday
Profile IconTyrone Bomba and David Earle joined ConsimWorld
Tuesday

Groups

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service