Can anyone recommend a really good book on the battle and the circumstances immediately surrounding it?

Views: 136


You need to be a member of ConsimWorld to add comments!

Join ConsimWorld

Comment by James Hodson on March 25, 2012 at 4:55am

I can support Lee's comments regarding Mark Adkin's 'The Gettysburg Companion'; extremely well written and illustrated with excellent maps and diagrams. Stephen Sears volume on the battle is on a par with his previous books. There are many books covering individual scenarios within the three days of the battle and I have found that having Bradley M. Gottfried's 'The Maps of Gettysburg' on hand as a companion helps to illuminate the written descriptions of the various episodes.

Comment by Lee Hanna on March 14, 2012 at 7:29pm

I was at Gettysburg Labor Day last year, and I shlepped The Gettysburg Companion by Mark Adkin around with me. It was great-- OB charts, terrain photos with overlays, maps aplenty.

Comment by Steve Arthur on March 8, 2012 at 9:48pm

Thank you Daniel..

Comment by Daniel Red Cloud Brown on March 8, 2012 at 6:45pm

I recently picked up Albert A. Nofi's ( yes, SPI's A.A. Nofi)  "The Gettysburg Campaign". It is excellent -pretty much what you would expect from a full S&T issue on Gettysburg ! With the usual side bars about various elements of the battle (biographies of the commanders,soldiers, personalities and -my favorite: "controversies"), you do get an excellent understanding of the Campaign and Battle. I enjoyed reading this; Of Course set up  3DoG and Command's "Lee's Greatest Gamble" .

       Not as detailed as any of Pfanz's works, nor approaching Coddington's Magna Opus, it is an excellent one-bookj overview ala SPI.  Get it, you wont be disappointed !

Comment by Steve Arthur on March 7, 2012 at 11:52pm

Thank you Robert..the political angle is something largely missing from Foote's works..I shall certainly be looking into these as well..

Comment by Robert Ryan on March 7, 2012 at 11:36pm

Bruce Cotton's trilogy is also highly recommended. His trilogy explores the political aspects of the civil war as well as the military aspects.  I picked up a copy of this in paperback from half priced books new for $5 a few years ago. Here is the link at Amazon

Comment by Steve Arthur on March 7, 2012 at 4:45pm

Already have Foote's excellent books (re-reading as we speak)..narrowed down to Sears,Coddington and Shaara's novel..all available quite cheaply on Ebay..I'll probably end up getting all of them..

Comment by Steve Arthur on March 7, 2012 at 4:31pm

Thanks guys..

Comment by Bill on March 7, 2012 at 4:20pm

I will 2nd Killer Angels

Comment by Steve Trauth on March 7, 2012 at 4:18pm

Killer Angels is pretty faithful to the history ( despite being historical fiction - basically the fictitious part is the dialogue is mostly made up by the author.

I read Stephen Sears' book on Antietam and it was very good, and know that he has one on Gettysburg. Plus if you don't have Foote's Trilogy, the chapter he wrote on Gettysburg was published separately as: Stars in the Courses.

One group that I want to get some day are the books by Pfanz on the battle (I think he has 2 titles specicially on the 1st and 2nd days, and then a third but I don't recall if that was only about the 3rd day or a more generalised coverage.

Help Center

Latest Activity

Edgar Gallego added a discussion to the group zun tzu

Connection problems with ZunTzu

I can't use ZunTzu for online gaming. If I try to be a HOST, it seems there is something wrong, and…See More
10 hours ago
Steven Rugge commented on brian s. b.'s group zun tzu
"Hi Michael,     Sure, we can give it a try.  After our successful try a month…"
12 hours ago
Michael Wilding commented on brian s. b.'s group zun tzu
"Steve Rugge, can we connect.  I am trying to document how we got ZT working together."
14 hours ago
Michael Wilding and Edgar Gallego are now friends
15 hours ago
Michael Wilding commented on brian s. b.'s group zun tzu
"It looks like we can chat in the "Main Room" of this site."
15 hours ago
Michael Wilding commented on brian s. b.'s group zun tzu
"Sure let's give it a try. How do I contact you?"
15 hours ago
Michael Wilding commented on brian s. b.'s group zun tzu
"Just ignore the server error message and "host anyway".  Then enter your IP…"
17 hours ago
Edgar Gallego updated their profile
21 hours ago




CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service