Iran: Trying to Control the Uncontrollable

Events in Iran since election day on June 12 have been truly breathtaking. The Islamist status quo faces a crisis of legitimacy, very reminiscent of that which raged through Eastern Europe twenty years ago, and the upsurge of popular rage further calls to mind the popular wrath that drove Shah Muhammed Reza Pahlavi from the Peacock Throne thirty years ago.

In an insightful blog post on Saturday, Laura Secor of The New Yorker asks the question though: Will this end with Wenceslaus Square, or Tienanmen Square? Can Iran have a Velvet Revolution, akin to that in Prague, or bloody repression, as in Beijing in 1989?

Michael Hirsch in Newsweek also addresses the issue, today. He points out the inherent vulnerabilities of the Islamic Republic, and that there might not be a right answer for the clerics. The could hold onto power for now, but the regime's shortcomings of legitimacy bode ill for its future.

Views: 82


You need to be a member of ConsimWorld to add comments!

Join ConsimWorld

Comment by Jim Werbaneth on June 17, 2009 at 10:15am
That's interesting. However, did it reflect Mousavi's surge in the last three weeks?

Also even if the election were perfectly legitimate, Iran has such a history of rigging elections, including through the Guardian Council's refusal to vet reformists, that it would be reasonable to expect the worst.
Comment by Gerald-Markus Zabos on June 17, 2009 at 8:34am
I can't tell if the outcome was predetermined in any way, but this article might give a view on what an independent survey during May 2009 found out:

In their way, the surprise was not a surprise.
Comment by Jim Werbaneth on June 17, 2009 at 7:03am
You mean that they're not still alive?!?!?

I honestly don't know how anyone could trust this election to have even a modicum of legitimacy. There were no independent monitors, none from the opposition either, no confidentiality in voting, and illiterate voters were "assisted" by government poll workers, who owed their jobs to the regime. In addition, the results were so far out of whack with any logical expectations, and the ballots were counted and certified so quickly, that one has to believe that the outcome was predetermined.
Comment by Gerald-Markus Zabos on June 17, 2009 at 5:21am
Laura Secor's assumption "There can be no question that the June 12, 2009, Iranian presidential election was stolen" might look insightful, but she presents evidence with the quality of people saying Elvis and Andy Kaufman are still alive.

Transition to more western style democracy rights will happen in future with slow speed, but the fall of Islamic Republic will never be a matter of talks. Why should it ?

Help Center

Latest Activity

Jim Werbaneth commented on Jim Werbaneth's blog post Line of Departure at Origins!
"Well, all the presentations went well, I think. It was also great meeting up with old friends,…"
Wayne Rotella commented on Mark DAgosta's photo
Mark DAgosta posted a photo

Land of the Two Rivers: Iraq War

Playtest map for upcoming game "Land of the Two Rivers", my first attempt at game design.…
Joe Admire joined Matt Severns's group


Buyin', Sellin' and good ol' fashioned horse tradin.......Can't find what you need? Go to the CSW…See More
Steve K commented on Steve K's blog post Games I'm Playing 2019
"Gaming Session in Cedar Rapids: June10-13. Pacific Tide (3rd US loss I have played!) The US Civil…"
Larry Banaszak is now a member of ConsimWorld
David Kazmierczak updated their profile
Profile IconMarek Dąbrowski, AJE SAKAMOTO and Nick Cartel joined ConsimWorld




CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2019   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service