What does board wargaming do a PC wargame cannot?

What does board wargaming do a PC wargame cannot?

^ More at the link

That is a good question. People often ask me why I bother playing these huge board wargames when I can just play almost the same thing with a Matrix Games PC title or a John Tiller game.

Views: 266

Comment

You need to be a member of ConsimWorld to add comments!

Join ConsimWorld

Comment by Christian A. Strasser on January 14, 2015 at 11:24am

My main reason for loving physical games is also the tactile sensation as well as the ability to see a big situation in one sweep.

And while I love computer games, with a PC game, you are locked into the assumptions and model that the developer has made.  While with cardboard, you are free to mash up different games:  A map from one with the counters from another; try a different game's CRT to even things up, etc.

You can add factors to the counters, play with house rules, change up the reinforcement schedule to reflect better / different information, make corrections, etc. 

And, barring a disaster, you are also able to play with the physical game forever.  I have some beloved computer games for which I'm keeping a variety of virtual systems running so that I can fire them up once in a while.  At some point, they're going to disappear.  A disk crash, media failure or inability to maintain them.

Comment by Lance Runolfsson on January 11, 2015 at 3:38am

cardboard has two strong points

1] The Big Picture: You can see everything at a glance. 

2] Rules changes and modifications are easy if you don't have to modify the physical components.

3] Much Greater variety in products

That said I play most of my "Board Games" on Vassal now and most of the games I want to play have small enough maps that I can zoom out enough to see the whole thing. Down side to Vassal is if you can't follow the instructions to make a useable module you are dependent upon the kindness of others. So whether or not there is a VASSAL module or is likely to be one restricts my choice in games. But still way more VASSAL modules than computer games.

Comment by Nate on January 9, 2015 at 6:51pm

If sim cloud cover and false intel could limit info on a map we would better appreciate cardboard.

Comment by John Kranz on January 7, 2015 at 2:17pm

For me it comes down to the tactile feel of having a game in front of me and being able to view the entire expanse. Especially if it's something I find graphically appealing, like a La Bataille type game or anything that fits one's fancy. I guess it's akin to the argument of eBook reader vs. physical book....

Help Center

Latest Activity

Ian Schofield posted a photo

Shiva Group First

The third ever show Shiva was entered into and he won the Hound Group. My wife was thrilled. The…
yesterday
Nathan posted a video

'The Grand Campaign' [4 - FINAL] - Serbien muss sterbien (2 Nov to 23 Dec - 1914)

'The Grand Campaign, The Battle for Serbia 1914' 1914: Serbien Muss Sterbien [GMT Games 2015] Designer: Michael Resch
Tuesday
Profile IconKevin Strong, Jose Luis Gomez and Kenneth Trout joined ConsimWorld
Monday
Ian Schofield posted a photo

Group 4th

Shiva is very tired after his second dog show of the day.
Monday
Grofaz joined Eric Walters's group
Thumbnail

Gaming Contemporary Tactical Ground Combat

Discuss your favorite games/systems/scenarios covering pre-WWII to hypothetical future tactical…See More
May 17
Jim Millard commented on Brian Blad's group World At War
"Anybody out there have the Compendium Vol. 2 that they want to part with?"
May 17
Profile IconDon Easter, Jason Moffat, javier guitian rivas and 1 more joined ConsimWorld
May 17
Joseph replied to Chuang Shyue Chou's discussion What are you reading?
"Read: " Slavery, Terrorism and Islam" by Peter Hammond. A fascinating read and thoroughly…"
May 16

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2019   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service