There are those SPI games that have bit the dust over time--some for deservedly good reasons--and others that we still keep playing even after all these many years.  I thought I'd devote a section to those that we break out now and then to sit down and play.  Call them classics--call them whatever; we like them and, at least in our mind, they have never been superseded.  

What SPI games have you kept over the years and don't think you'll ever replace with anything newer or shinier?  Why?

Views: 2567

Replies to This Discussion

I know, I know, it takes eons and scores of turns to see any progress in this uber-monster game.  But what other game out there even comes close to the scope, scale, and epic nature of this title?  There just isn't one!  Of course, Decision Games knew a good thing when they saw it and just republished the game lock, stock, and barrel!  Great game to get familiar with the dynastic struggles of Europe in a highly interactive and interesting way....

This doesn't have to be that long. I've brought it to many many game meetups

with people who would never consider a big wargame, and they've had a lot of fun

with it. It's got such a fluid system that each round is fairly fast.  Overall,

you can get scenarios done with newer players in an 8 hour session - much

shorter with people who already are familiar with the game.

Another amazing Strategy and Tactics issue game that has deservedly acheived that status of "wargame classic!"  Admittedly, I play the Avalon Hill version of this game, which names the leader counters, gives you scenarios covering each year of the Seven Years War in Europe, and also offered a variant on the War of Austrian Succession/The Silesian Wars within the pages of The General magazine.  No matter. All this is merely chrome built on a solid chassis and power train that SPI furnished!  

When this game came out in Strategy and Tactics, me and my friends could not stop playing it.  My copy of the issue games is falling apart at the seams--the map is disintegrating, the counters rounded and faded.  I had to get the Avalon Hill version of the game to keep playing it.  Some might wonder if it could be fairly be called a true wargame but I assure you that it is.  While there is exploration and economics, it's still highly competitive with a lot of warfare/combat to be had!

If not the best of the BLUE AND GRAY folio games, it certainly deserves a top spot there.  Decision Games redesigned and released it but--once again--some will say it doesn't quite stand up to the original in terms of competitive potential and ease of play.  Let's face it, BLUE AND GRAY series games are basically NAPOLEON AT WATERLOO transplanted into the Civil War, but at least this was a very successful effort.  Nothing else out there that covers this battle as well in such a compact format.

Do you guys recommend buying the old SPI title Battle for Germany or waiting for DG to get it through the pledge and production process?
same thoughts go for War in Europe?
Thx

Bill
Sorry for my last post. New mechanics here. I was referring to buying the old SPI titles Battle for Germany and War in Europe. Should I buy the old SPI versions or wait for DG to get enough pledges and produce them? Are DG reworks of old SPI games really better. Let me know before I buy Wacht am Rhein!

Best,

Bill

Bill, DG already redid BATTLE FOR GERMANY and it adds a few counters to the game, but basically it's the same as the original.  If you've got the old one, you don't need to get the new one.  If you missed the old one (and can't get one for cheap), consider getting the DG version.

Regarding the DG version of WAR IN EUROPE, it's greatly, greatly improved over the original.  Allies can FINALLY do their own production (vice having a reinforcement schedule affected by the U-boat war) and there are a few other improvements (like adding U.S. Marines!). Plays a lot like the older game, which has its pluses and minuses.  DG's pledge is for yet a newer edition with more fixes.  The issue with WAR IN EUROPE is that it's basically the old SPI "Divisional Series" system with a strategic frame grafted around it.  Unlike other re-releases, DG didn't mess with the basic design.  You might wait for the newer edition and see how that compares; you may want the current one and it will go cheaper when the new edition comes out.

WACHT AM RHEIN II--very, very cumbersome beast that looks nothing like the original SPI version (I'll admit I'm not a fan of that version either).  Very fiddly.  Gorgeously produced, however.  Rules will give you a headache!  

Eric,

Thanks for the update! I didn't realize that DG had already put these titles out as I saw them on the pledge page. So those are the remakes of the remakes?

Sure looks that way!  You can never stop tinkering!  

When I saw the price of a DG remake of War In Europe on BGG I quickly decided I'd just pledge for the new copy that includes unit IDs!  What are your thoughts on DG's pledge attempt to make Battle for Germany a mini-monster?  It looks good as is and I am going to buy one on payday but a monster with historical unit IDs sounds compelling.

 

My best,

 

Bill

When you get the new version of WAR IN EUROPE, I think you'll do just fine with the 1944 scenario; think it would substitute for the new BATTLE FOR GERMANY game....

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Joseph replied to Chuang Shyue Chou's discussion What are you reading?
"Read: "Empire of Horses: The First Nomadic Civilization and the Making of China" by John…"
13 hours ago
Eric Walters commented on Kid's photo
Thumbnail

Coldwar

"Heck, I'd use this game for my ASL and ASLSK games, it looks so good!  I can imagine a…"
yesterday
Eric Walters commented on Kid's photo
Thumbnail

Black Hawk Down

"Wow--this is great!  I like the hexes far better than the squares for this particular game!"
yesterday
Eric Walters left a comment for Fred Thompson
"Fred, thanks for updating your profile!  I think your favorite games list has a great balance…"
yesterday
Fred Thompson updated their profile
yesterday
Kid posted photos
yesterday
Eric Walters replied to John Kranz's discussion What are you playing?
"Have got AVALANCHE: THE SALERNO LANDINGS by GDW on the wargame table and have it--at last--set up.…"
Monday
Joseph replied to John Kranz's discussion What are you playing?
"Played: S&T 324, "After the Fall". Two Battles on the last years of the Western Roman…"
Monday

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

© 2020   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service