Just got my copy of Poland Defiant in my mailbox.  Of course, I had to set it up on the table and start playing it.  My first impressions upon punching the counters and reading the rules are that this is more of an old school type operational-game, but using formation activations such as we see in other games by this company (e.g., Konigsberg: The Soviet Attack on East Prussia, 1945).  The map detail is marvelous and even minor features like villages have significant terrain effects; in this case, defenders in villages can ignore the first hex of retreat.  The graphic feel of the map is pure Joe Youst--it looks a lot like his other Eastern Front cartographic treatments.  The game covers only the first ten days of the operation in ten turns.  It also doesn't contain variant rules like one sees in Ty Bomba's old Poland '39: The Nightmare Begins, or even the more recent Lock 'N Load's Summer Lightning: The Invasion of Poland, 1939.  But for those who want to pit their skills in the actual historical situation in an easy-to-learn, playable and interactive format, this game delivers.

Views: 19

Replies to This Discussion

Am slowly documenting a solitaire play-by-play of the game on BGG here.  See what you think.  Will try to post more frequently on this; had some health issues distracting me for a while but those are now resolved and I aim to chug along on this.  Given it's the 80th anniversary of the 1939 Polish Campaign, this seemed appropriate.  I really like this game!

RSS

Help Center

Latest Activity

Eric Walters replied to Eric Walters's discussion Breakthrough and Benchmark SPI Designs--Your Assessments? in the group All things SPI
"Russ, I definitely perceive CITYFIGHT: MODERN COMBAT IN THE URBAN ENVIRONMENT (1979) as being…"
21 hours ago
Eric Walters left a comment for Garibaldi Mangiapane
"Welcome to the CONSIMWORLD Social Website, Garibaldi!  Oh, you like the big monsters.  So…"
21 hours ago
Garibaldi Mangiapane is now a member of ConsimWorld
21 hours ago
Ian Schofield posted a photo

H&M Fraustadt 30YW Minis

Horse & Musket from Hollandspiele, set up for Fraustadt, but using 30YW minis - I am waiting…
yesterday
Joseph C. Beard III replied to Eric Walters's discussion Breakthrough and Benchmark SPI Designs--Your Assessments? in the group All things SPI
"Greetings Eric and Russ: I have been thinking about the general topic of this forum and…"
Monday
Joseph C. Beard III replied to Eric Walters's discussion Breakthrough and Benchmark SPI Designs--Your Assessments? in the group All things SPI
"Greetings Russ: The chronology of SPI's several pre-KURSK attempts to inject a…"
Sunday
Russ Gifford replied to Eric Walters's discussion Breakthrough and Benchmark SPI Designs--Your Assessments? in the group All things SPI
"Joe's point on WELLINGTON'S VICTORY is certainly apt. One thing I regret to this day…"
Sunday
Russ Gifford replied to Eric Walters's discussion Breakthrough and Benchmark SPI Designs--Your Assessments? in the group All things SPI
"I guess I see CITYFIGHT as a breakthrough that went no where, but could have gone anywhere. I…"
Sunday

Groups

Events

Members

CSW Related Links

Please be sure to check-out these CSW services.

© 2019   Created by John Kranz.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service